Global Agency & Distributor Dispute Network

Global Agency & Distributor Dispute Network ·

Connect the franchise earnings claim to Item 19 and its data

Record the actual franchise earnings representation and compare it with Item19 and written substantiation before relying on it.

When a franchise seller presents a sales or earnings figure, preserve the exact claim and ask how it connects to the Franchise Disclosure Document. Record whether the figure describes gross sales, profit or another measure. A number becomes more useful for evaluation when its source, assumptions and limits are visible alongside the presentation.

For franchise sellers covered by the federal rule, section 436.9 addresses financial performance representations and their reasonable basis, written substantiation and inclusion in Item 19. The FTC's September 2020 buying guide explains the disclosure framework and identifies limited situations involving existing-outlet records or supplemental information. Have an experienced adviser assess the actual representation and applicable requirements rather than treating a sales slide as an approved forecast.

Create a claim record with the speaker, date, exact wording, amount, period, outlet group and document reference. Keep the presentation or message in its original form. Ask the seller to identify the corresponding Item 19 passage and provide the written support available on request. If a statement does not match the document, preserve the difference and ask for clarification before relying on it.

For example, a seller may show an average annual sales amount for a group of outlets. Ask which outlets and period produced the average, what was excluded and what expenses remain to be paid. The FTC guide explains that gross sales do not show actual costs or profit. Work through the real data with an accountant rather than replacing missing expenses with a confident assumption.

Check geographical and operating differences that matter to the proposed location. Record whether the data concern company-owned or franchised outlets and what assumptions are being made about the new business. Keep historical information separate from a projection and identify any material qualifications. Section 436.9 also calls for a warning that individual results may differ from the represented result.

Read any questionnaire about representations received before signing it. Preserve truthful answers and the supporting communications, including information provided orally. Ask counsel about inconsistent documents or wording that does not reflect the actual discussions. A final review should reconcile the claim record, Item 19, substantiation and the decision-maker's understanding of the risk.

The site shop includes business folders, scanners and planning supplies for financial review records. Compare products for keeping tables readable and versions organized, and purchase only the tools needed to inspect the actual evidence rather than equipment based on an assumed earnings outcome.

Sources and further reading

This is general information. Check the relevant authority or manufacturer for the rules, compatibility and terms that apply to your situation.

More practical guides